IRS Letter 3193 Gives You 30 Days to Reach Tax Court

Letter 3193 is the IRS Appeals decision from your collection due process hearing. Here's what the letter means and how to decide whether to go to Tax Court.

If you're holding IRS Letter 3193, you've already requested a collection due process hearing and made it through Appeals, which most business owners never do. Whether Appeals ruled for you or against you, this letter gives you 30 days to take your case to US Tax Court. If you miss that deadline, in most cases the decision becomes final, and you lose the protection from levy you've been counting on.

Before I became an IRS defense attorney, I was an IRS agent. In this article I'll explain what this letter means and what you should do with it.

Video

Watch my full video on this topic below, or watch on YouTube.

What Letter 3193 means

The title of the letter generally reads Notice of Determination Concerning Collection Action under IRC 6320 or 6330. Those are sections of the Internal Revenue Code. Section 6320 deals with federal tax liens, and section 6330 deals with levies.

You received this letter because of one of two earlier notices. Either you got Letter 3172, which is a lien notice, or you got Letter 1058 or LT11, the final notice of intent to levy. You then filed Form 12153 within 30 days to get a collection due process (CDP) hearing in front of the IRS Independent Office of Appeals. Letter 3193 is the written decision from that hearing, and it's essentially the end of the administrative appeal road.

Read the attachment carefully

The letter may sustain the lien or levy in full, sustain part of it, or reflect a resolution you negotiated. Most of the letter is boilerplate, so make sure you read the attachment, which explains what Appeals did and why it did it.

By law, Appeals has to do three things in a CDP hearing. It has to verify that the IRS followed the law and its own procedures, including that the tax was properly assessed and the notices were properly sent. It has to consider the issues you raised, such as an installment agreement, an offer in compromise, currently not collectible status, lien withdrawal, subordination, or in some cases a challenge to the tax itself. And it has to apply what's called the balancing test, which weighs the government's need to collect against your legitimate concern that collection be no more intrusive than necessary.

When you read the attachment, look for what Appeals said was missing. Very often I see a statement that the taxpayer did not provide the requested financial information, or that the taxpayer was not in filing compliance because there are unfiled returns. Those statements tell you whether or not you have a case worth taking to court.

The deadline is 30 days

If you're familiar with a notice of deficiency, you may expect to have 90 days to go to Tax Court. With Letter 3193 you only have 30 days from the date on the letter to file a petition.

This matters a great deal for a business owner who owes six figures to the IRS. If you requested your CDP hearing on time after a levy notice, the IRS generally can't move forward with the levy during the hearing, and the same is true while a timely Tax Court petition is pending. Oftentimes that's the only thing keeping a levy off your company's bank accounts and receivables.

Once the 30 days have passed, the decision is final and that protection is gone. If Appeals upheld the levy, the revenue officer can go ahead with collection. You also won't get another CDP hearing for the same tax or period.

Should you file a Tax Court petition?

Not necessarily. Not every decision from Appeals should go to Tax Court, and there are three questions I would ask first.

1. Did Appeals make a real error? In most collection cases, the Tax Court reviews the decision for what it calls abuse of discretion. The court is asking whether the decision was arbitrary, unreasonable or without a sound basis, rather than whether it would have decided the case differently, and that standard is very deferential to the IRS. A case you could win would be one where Appeals ignored evidence you gave them, got the rules wrong, left out a required verification, or turned down an alternative with no legitimate reason.

2. What's in the record? Business owners are often surprised by this one. In many cases the court will largely look only at what Appeals had in front of it. If you didn't submit your financial statements, weren't current on your filings, or never proposed a collection alternative, the court generally won't fix that for you. You also can't raise new issues for the first time in Tax Court.

3. Can you challenge the tax itself? Only in limited situations, generally. Someone who already received a notice of deficiency, or had some other chance to dispute what they owe, generally can't go back and reargue the tax in a CDP case. If you never had that chance, the court can look at the liability fresh.

What to do if you received Letter 3193

First, calendar the 30-day petition deadline as soon as you receive the letter, counting from the date on the letter. Then read the attachment, identify what Appeals relied on and what it said was missing, and compare that to what you actually submitted. You're trying to figure out whether there's a real error or a gap you created by not providing information.

If there's an error worth fighting, file the petition well before day 30. I would file it as soon as possible. The Tax Court accepts electronic filing, and the filing fee is modest.

If there's no real error, I wouldn't spend the time and money on a petition. Pivot to the strongest resolution still available and get into compliance by filing your required returns and starting estimated payments, because no collection alternative is going to work for a business that's still falling behind.

This is your last chance to get in front of an independent judge before the collection decision is final, and you only have 30 days to do it. If you owe six figures to the IRS and are holding Letter 3193, start acting today, and feel free to reach out to me for a free evaluation of your case.